Insider Gaming
Menu
·
·

Sony Wins PlayStation Digital Games Lawsuit

Back in November 2023, the go-ahead was given to a lawsuit concerning Sony and its PlayStation Store digital games pricing practices. However, after months and years of litigation, the court has ruled in Sony’s favor.

Sony was issued a lawsuit in August 2022, and updated details on the motion against Sony and PlayStation being approved can be found via PlayStationYouOweUs, which said: ‘The lawsuit was filed in August 2022 alleging Sony has abused its dominant position in the market by charging excessive prices to its customers for games and in-app purchases.’

Sony Prevails in UK Class-Action Lawsuit About PlayStation Games Price

playstation logo
Credit to PlayStation

Here’s what The Game Business reported about the class action:

‘Sony has defeated a major $2.6 billion UK class action lawsuit over the price of PlayStation games.

The lawsuit was brought about by Alex Neill, who is representing consumers that purchased PlayStation digital content between August 2016 and February 2026. The action accused PlayStation of having a ‘near monopoly’ on digital games and add-on content on PlayStation platforms. The case argued that Sony sets strict terms and conditions on developers, and charges a 30% commission on every purchase, which results in “excessive and unfair prices”. It claimed the prices are out of proportion to the costs.

But London’s Competition Appeal Tribunal rejected this, and said the claim failed to establish that PlayStation infringed competition law. As a result, it has dismissed the case in its entirety.

The lawsuit argued that once you own a PlayStation, you are trapped within the ecosystem. The Tribunal disagreed, and ruled that Sony competes within a wider ‘systems market’ with the likes of Xbox, Nintendo and PC. It also ruled that gamers can buy physical games (at least for now).

The court said that forcing PlayStation to allow third-party stores onto the platform would be expensive, complex and could impact security. It added that under competition law, there was no legal duty for Sony to do this.

Finally, the court didn’t find pricing to be unfair. It said that Alex Neill had failed to prove Sony’s profit margins were excessive, especially as console makers sell hardware cheaply to make money back on game sales. Furthermore, the tribunal said there [was] no evidence that rival stores would have brought pricing down.

PlayStation still faces similar class actions in Australia, [the] Netherlands, and Portugal at an earlier stage.’

Is Sony right? Let us know your thoughts on the Insider Gaming Discord server.


For more Insider Gaming content, check out ‘Grand Theft Auto 6 Review Embargo Date Details,’ and don’t forget to sign up for our newsletter.

Written by
Andrew Highton
Evergreen Editor

Andy is Insider Gaming's Senior Evergreen Editor and has been in the games journalism sphere in one way or another for over 7 years. His video game taste is as…

More from Andrew Highton
MOBILE APP

Level Up Your Gaming News

Real-time news, exclusive podcasts, push alerts, and a better reading experience.
Available on iOS & Android

Comments

Drop a comment

Keep it civil. Your email won't be published.

More Posts

PS5 Gets Another Security Update For GTA 6 Launch In 14.23 Patch

The PlayStation 5 has seen yet another firmware update, once again improving the console’s security ahead of GTA 6’s release.

GTA 6 Has 62 Bird Types, Confirms Rockstar Games

Rockstar Games has already revealed how many different species GTA 6 has, and you’ll be searching far and wide for them.

INTERVIEW: Tarkov’s Nikita Buyanov On PvE vs. PvP: ‘I Want Everybody To Be Happy’

In an exclusive interview with Nikita Buyanov, we got the Tarkov head’s two cents on the PvE vs. PvP debate in the extraction space.

New GTA 6 Screenshots Showcase Intense Weather Systems

On social media, six new GTA 6 screenshots have surfaced, focusing specifically on the game’s incredible weather systems.