If you’re at all linked to the extraction shooter space, you’ll be more than slightly aware of the PvE vs. PvP debate that has been raging for the longest time. It peaked when ARC Raiders dropped without any PvE offering last year, and it burned bright coming into 2026. As more extraction titles have launched, like Modern Warfare 4’s DMZ mode, it has only gotten more prevalent as a discussion.
I recently sat down with Nikita Buyanov, the head of the studio at Battlestate Games and arguably the founding father of extraction games. His title, Escape from Tarkov, pioneered the genre, which was slapped with the label several years ago, and it remains the most popular and well-rounded game in the space.
During our conversation, I asked for his two cents on the PvE vs. PvP debate.
Just Enjoy What You Enjoy
Every extraction shooter on the market has fallen into the PvE vs. PvP debate in recent months. For some, it’s a non-starter, as they’re nothing but PvE, but for others, walking the line between the split audience has proven to be a huge concern.
For instance, a petition surfaced recently, begging Activision to add a PvE mode to Call of Duty’s new DMZ platform, an extraction mode built into Modern Warfare 4. Similarly, Embark Studios tested a PvE ‘toggle’ in ARC Raiders in a bid to appeal to that side of the community.
Marathon got a PvE mode, Arena Breakout: Infinite received a permanent PvE-themed mode, and Gray Zone Warfare, an extraction-adjacent game, made a more decisive split between PvE and PvP modes.
Escape from Tarkov has been at the forefront of this debate for ages, as two years ago, the game received a full-fledged PvE version that allows users to traverse the entire title without ever meeting another player in combat. It’s the preferred way to play for some, and Nikita recently revealed that, at present, around 60% of players are on the PvE platform.
I asked him if he listens to the debate, if the team considers what other developers are doing, and if he believes that all extraction games should have a PvE offering.
We just do what we’re doing.
We want to have the game available for different kinds of audiences. Right now, with this split, people are trying to make something out of it. I already told people, this is the natural cycle of PvP players. The PvE crowd, they’re more established. They go through the wipe; they’re constantly online, not fluctuating; they’re stable.
They play when they want, how they want, without being afraid of losing progress or something. It’s natural. It’s understandable.
He became more enthused as he spoke about the topic, which has proven to be a passionate one on social media. Folks have made it their mission to represent one side of the fence or the other in recent weeks as the topic has fully disrupted the space.
People want some kind of drama out of nothing. They think that PvP is dying.
No, it’s not.
We boosted PvE because I like PvE. I like PvP. I like Tarkov, basically! I don’t care about PvE and PvP; I want everybody to be happy about everything. This is the nature of people; they just want to find some problems, the potential to start arguing about it.
He then made a bold statement about not taking inspiration from other developers, indicating it’s the exact opposite:
I already knew there would be a moment where we would do something for PvE, for PvP, vice versa.
We’re not afraid of it; the cycle of PvP goes up and down towards the end of the wipe or season. That’s totally fine. I’m not taking into consideration other games.
I don’t need to do that because everyone takes inspiration from us.
Escape from Tarkov arguably set the bar for extraction shooters, and the way it handles PvE is the perfect solution. When you separate these modes and allow them to operate as standalone entities, you split the community, but you fully facilitate a platform for both audiences to thrive.
It’s tough to get the balance right, but I’d say that Battlestate is doing it better than any extraction-focused developer out there.
Are you a PvP or a PvE player in Escape from Tarkov? Let us know your thoughts about the game on the Insider Gaming Discord server.
For more Insider Gaming coverage, check out the new AI systems coming to Escape from Tarkov, and don’t forget to sign up for our free weekly newsletter




Comments