Insider Gaming
Menu
·
·

MindsEye Becomes 2025’s Worst-Rated Game As Reviews Creep In

MindsEye has been suffering immeasurably since being released on June 10. The third-person ‘GTA competitor’ is the debut title of Build a Rocket Boy, a new studio headed by former Rockstar legend, Leslie Benzies. The game has plummeted in the rankings due to its being wildly buggy and inherently flawed.

Now that the game has managed to receive some reviews from popular outlets, it has been aggregated on Metacritic, and the score reflects the quality of this title. At the time of writing, MindsEye had a Metascore of just 43, making it the worst-rated game to emerge in more than a year.


Unsightly

MindsEye has dominated trends on social media in recent days, but only because users are sharing clips of bugs and bizarre AI behaviour in a game that was bolstered by so many ambitious promises ahead of release. As the debut title for Build a Rocket Boy, MindsEye stands to threaten the future of the studio, and the review aggregation is a clear reflection of that.

On Metacritic, MindsEye has managed to secure a critic score of 43 (Generally Unfavourable). The user score sits at a paltry 2.4 out of 10.

To put that score into perspective, the last game to score that low was Quantum Error, a terrible title from TeamKill Media released in November 2023. It picked up a Metascore of 40 and was slated by users everywhere.

In May 2023, Daedalic Entertainment released The Lord of the Rings: Gollum, one of the worst-rated games we’ve ever seen. It became a laughingstock of a title at launch and caused the studio to reconsider its future in the development space after a Metascore of just 33 was produced.

That’s the impact that negative reviews can have on a studio, but a recent roadmap revealed by Build a Rocket Boy for MindsEye shows that the team is at least determined to try rescuing the game.

Have you played MindsEye? Let me know what you think about the game on the Insider Gaming forum.


For more Insider Gaming coverage, check out the news that the most popular Fallout game has hit 230 million downloads

Written by
Grant Taylor-Hill
Senior Editor and Esports Lead

Grant has been gaming for 30+ years and in the industry for 10+. You'll probably find him playing a post-apocalyptic game or an extraction shooter somewhere.

More from Grant Taylor-Hill
MOBILE APP

Level Up Your Gaming News

Real-time news, exclusive podcasts, push alerts, and a better reading experience.
Available on iOS & Android

Comments

More Posts

The Witcher 4 is Aiming For 60FPS on Consoles, But Series S Will be ‘Extremely Challenging’

CD Projekt Red has opened up about its PlayStation 5 Unreal Engine 5 demo and has said that it will be “extremely challenging” to get The Witcher 4 at 60FPS on the Xbox Series S.

Most Popular Fallout Game Has Hit 230 Million Downloads in Ten Years

Bethesda Game Studios has revealed the most popular Fallout game has hit a whopping 230 million downloads in ten years.

Summer Game Fest Viewership Grew 89% and Hit 50 Million Streams

It has been revealed that Summer Game Fest exploded this year, pulling in 89% more viewers than last year’s edition.

Xbox Game Pass Could be Getting Another Price Increase Soon

A new string of code in the xCloud website has been spotted which suggests that Xbox Game Pass could be seeing another price increase soon.