Starfield has been a topic of much contention in recent days. Following the release of Shattered Space, the game’s first major expansion, many fans were disappointed with an underwhelming piece of DLC that has failed to warrant such a long wait and a premium price point. That’s just the tip of the iceberg, though.
Many are still rueing Starfield’s rapid downfall, which was kickstarted not long after the game was released in September 2023. Recently, Emil Pagliarulo, a design director at Bethesda Game Studios, defended the space-faring RPG, aligning it closely with Fallout and The Elder Scrolls, two of the most legendary franchises in gaming history.
Perhaps Not
In a sitdown with GamesRadar, Emil Pagliarulo, whose work has spanned all three major franchises, said that Starfield ‘sits right next to’ Fallout and The Elder Scrolls as a series.
It exists in a unique space. It might not be everyone’s cup of tea. What is? We created a new IP, from the ground up, and an experience that is absolutely unique on consoles.
And I’m not saying Starfield is better or worse than any other game – just different in what we offer: that weird Bethesda blend of immersion, action, and RPG.
He used the word ‘unique’ a few times, suggesting that Starfield is building an entirely new fanbase that might not necessarily connect as easily with The Elder Scrolls or Fallout. That’s one of the things that has harmed Starfield since the moment the game dropped a year ago – the comparisons between Starfield and the decades-old series that preceded it.
Pagliarulo said that Starfield is now part of Bethesda Game Studios’ ‘Big Three’ games. Once upon a time, the developer said that it’s probably the best game Bethesda has ever made, but many would disagree. It has only been a year since Starfield was released after almost a decade of hype, but the player count has already dwindled outside of Game Pass.
Shattered Space pulled in mediocre reviews, games like Skyrim and Fallout 4 are outpacing Starfield on some platforms, and on content and streaming sites, Starfield is withering to nothing. Bethesda’s Todd Howard promised annual expansions for the title, but even Shattered Space wasn’t well anticipated – in another year, Bethesda might be delivering a DLC to a zeroed audience.
People defending Starfield might lean on the ’15 million players’ figure, but as of December 2023, the game had sold 13 million copies (including Game Pass, it’s thought), and how many of those gamers are still engaged today?
Are you still playing Starfield? Let us know on the Insider Gaming forum
For more Insider Gaming Coverage, check out the news about Halo Infinite’s third-person mode
Get a better engine also Indiana Jones looks like trash. Arkane should have been cut not Tango and Roundhouse.
Yeah, let’s close down the developer of Dishonored and Prey, I guess we haven’t lost enough this year /s
Unique? It’s essentially the same game fallout 4 is! Unique if you’re talking about setting or place names, but not gameplay it anything like that.
Every game Director wants their game/games praised so well beside legends within their industry but it isn’t up to them to say it. It is the player base/count and fans that is supposed to and this Director saying this just adds to him being an self-entitled egotistical idiot.
It suck’s this is how you get fired Todd when they speak for you. Just take the chance and bring Chris Avellone in to take over these franchises because clearly modern Bethesda and Obsidian suck I don’t blame Microsoft.
Refreshing article to read, there’s no bias and no punches pulled. This is how you regain followers as legacy media– by being honest and speaking to the gamers, not by catering to the general critic consensus (ie status quo) and game studios. Starfield is objectively not as good as ES and Fallout. In fact it’s been 12 years since Bethesda has released a game worth purchasing, and they know this, which is why they remastered and re-released that game 7 times since then. Starfield is unimaginative, bland, and launched with cut content to purposely delay to then release later as DLC and “new features” (What RPG game doesn’t launch with a map but includes one a year later?). It’s lazy, the writing is lazy, from the characters, to the plot, to the planets, down to the health bars, it’s just bland. No one wants to feel like the game they’re playing is more of a chore than fun, and Starfield certainly gives off that vibe, similarly to titles like Destiny and modern WoW.